Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

European Union

Mass surveillance and attack on encryption: Civil society protests against EU chat control plans

35 civil society organisations, including European Digital Rights (EDRi), the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the German Bar Association and the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), are raising the alarms on legislation the EU Commission is to present on 30 March. Similar to Apple’s highly controversial “SpyPhone” scheme, the EU Commission intends to oblige all providers of e-mail, chat or message services to search for and report CSAM by bulk intercepting, moni-toring and scanning the content of all citizens’ communications – even where they are so far securely end-to-end encrypted.

The human rights watchdogs call on the EU Commission to „ensure that people’s private commu-nications do not become collateral damage of the forthcoming legislation“, to target suspects rather than roll out mass surveillance and to prevent the creation of CSAM in the first place by exploring social and human interventions.[1] In its press release[2] EDRi warns that the proposal „would undermine the essence of end-to-end encryption“ and would „make the EU a world leader in the generalised surveillance of whole populations“. „How, then, would the EU be able to speak out when undemocratic regimes enact the same measures?“

MEP and civil liberties defender Patrick Breyer (German Pirate Party) comments:

“This EU Big Brother attack on our mobile phones by error-prone denunciation machines sear-ching our entire private communications is the first step in the direction of a Chinese-style sur-veillance state. Will the next step will be for the post office to open and scan all letters? Organised child pornography rings don‘t use e-mail or messengers. Indiscriminately searching all correspon-dence violates fundamental rights and will not protect children. It actually puts their private pic-tures at risk of falling into the wrong hands and criminalises children in many cases.“

Advertisement

In an expert opinion a former ECJ judge pointed out last year that the warrantless interception of private communications violates the case law of the European Court of Justice.[3] According to a poll 72% of citizens oppose the indiscriminate scanning of their private communications.[4]

[1] https://edri.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Civil-society-open-letter-Protecting-rights-and-freedoms-in-the-upcoming-legislation-to-effectively-tackle-child-abuse.pdf
[2] https://edri.org/our-work/private-communications-are-a-cornerstone-of-democratic-society-and-must-be-protected-in-online-csam-legislation/
[3] https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/former-ecj-judge-eu-plans-for-indiscriminate-screening-of-private-messages-chat-control-violate-fundamental-rights/
[4] https://www.patrick-breyer.de/en/poll-72-of-citizens-oppose-eu-plans-to-search-all-private-messages-for-allegedly-illegal-material-and-report-to-the-police/

Breyer‘s website on the proposal: chatcontrol.eu

Comments

Trending

Latest Tweets

Advertisement

You May Also Like

United Kingdom

Film director Ridley Scott has recalled the death of actor Oliver Reed while making the Oscar winning blockbuster Gladiator. Scott said hard-drinking Reed “just...

Business

The controversial Russian businessman Viktor Baturin, well-known for his years-long counterstanding with his wealthy sister Elena, widow of Moscow ex-mayor Yuri Luzhkov, is likely...

United Kingdom

The Tremeloes. Dave Munden centre Dave Munden the Tremeloes drummer – and often lead singer – with the 60s chart toppers has died. He...

United Kingdom

The Watneys Party Seven is making a comeback. The ubiquitous 70s beer was a bland fizzing bitter ridiculed by many. The drink’s insipidness helped...